Understanding The Possibility Of Claiming Two Auto Insurance Policies

2 min readMar 13, 2024

An auto insurance policy protects you against financial losses caused by accidents, theft, vandalism, or natural disasters. It is also required by law. There’s nothing unusual about people purchasing two insurance policies. Your car insurance may include a breakdown policy, but you are also paying for a separate breakdown policy, unaware that it comes with your insurance. Is it possible to have two auto insurance policies on one car? Are you able to file a claim with two different insurance companies at the same time?

What Is The Legality Of Having Two Auto Insurance Policies?

There is nothing illegal about having two auto insurance policies on the exact vehicle. It is, however, possible that your insurance company won’t cover the same car twice, and there is a possibility that you will have to obtain a second insurance policy from a different company. It is common for drivers to buy a second policy when they mistakenly believe that their first policy has expired. It is not uncommon to have a separate policy to cover their classics or exotics.

Can You File An Auto Insurance Claim With Two Different Insurance Companies Simultaneously?

Always remember that you can protect yourself from loss but not profit from it. Having two auto insurance policies but filing the same claim with two different companies is not. If two insurance companies compensate you for the same claim, this amounts to double compensation, which could be considered insurance fraud. There shouldn’t be a difference in payment whether you have two insurance policies or just one.

Does It Make Sense To Have Only One Auto Insurance Policy?

You can end up violating the policies of your car insurance provider when you have two approaches. You may also violate a clause in your policy. You might also be viewed as a fraud by your insurer. In an accident, both insurers may refuse to pay your claim, putting you and your co-owner in a tight spot. You and your co-owner must insure the vehicle with a single policy to avoid confusion and nonpayment of claims. The procedure can be in both your names or shared with another person.

What Are The Ways An Insurance Company Detects Auto Insurance Fraud?

Double coverage does not necessarily mean you are committing car insurance fraud. To obtain restitution for unjust enrichment, an insurance company must prove the following:

— Policyholders have benefited at the expense of insurance providers.

— Policyholders are aware of the benefits of the claim payment.

— Even though they know the profits, the policyholder has retained the use.

Even though it is not illegal to have more than one auto insurance policy on a vehicle, it can lead to confusion and an unpaid claim. Therefore, you should avoid having double insurance on a car unless it is essential.




Fincrew financial marketplace enables customers to compare and apply auto insurance, office insurance, gadget insurance, travel insurance, car extended warranty